Re: Columbus Day Protest

Peter d'Errico (derrico@titan.ucc.umass.edu)
Sat, 16 Nov 1991 20:42:17 EST


In response to
anchor.esd.sgi.com!dearborn@sgi.com (Lyn Dearborn)
sjpalmer@kuhub.cc.ukans.edu says:

> | The same goes for the wonderful history of direct action, confrontation, and
> | hell-raising that exists behind EVERY MAJOR ADVANCE IN HISTORY for women,

Lyn replies:

> the opportunity of seeing, first-hand, how self-destructive it has been in
> the past for the Indian Community to WHINE about every thing that offends

Seems to me that this raises a good question: what is the difference between
"confrontation" and "whining"? I had the sense that there was some whining
going on around the tomahawk chant down south at that ballgame; but I also
saw an element of confrontation in the critique. The main thing I saw was
the variety of perspectives among Indians: no single viewpoint.

In a sort of PS, Lyn says:

> .... by the way, don't read anything into me not responding to your mail
> until now .... I had surgery on my wrist (CTS from too much typing) 3

I have just set myself up at a drafting table; standing up to do all my work
seems to be a good move. I can raise and lower the table to give myself
some variation in position.

--
Peter d'Errico                                              phone: 413-545-2003
Legal Studies Department                                    fax:   413-545-1640
University of Massachusetts/Amherst 01003           dErrico@titan.ucc.umass.edu