Query: Lakota vs Caucasians

Wilson Riles Jr. (wriles@igc.apc.org)
Mon, 6 Mar 1995 17:04:05 -0800


I could use some help. A professor at a college that I am
attending made some statements about the Lakota or Plains people
that I do not think is true. He was talking about the
Indo-European herding people who swept down on their horses from
between the Caucus and Ural mountains to dominate the agricultural
people of Europe. He claimed that it was their life style of
following the herds of Europe which gave them a religion which
sanctioned the strongest, most violent male receiving control of
almost all that was good. This was, in my professors opinion, the
natural example that was displayed by the behavior of the animal
herds that the Indo-European Caucasians depended on for their
lives. Scarcity, caused by a change in the weather he said, forced
them out of the herding area; and their life style and religious
belief carried them across Europe raping, murdering, and
stealing.

I asked him why the Plains People of the American Midwest who
followed the buffalo herds did not also have a religion that
sanctioned "the strongest male takes all." Why did the Lakota
People develop a religion that was more respectful of other people
and the earth. My professor's answer was that the Plains People
did not have the horse until late in their history. That some how
walking with the herds made them more respectful of others and the
land. He said that when they did get the horse, their religion
changed to be more like the Caucasians!

Is he right! I would appreciate enlightenment on this issue. I
would appreciate any references that I might read and bring to my
professor to show him what is the true situation. Personally I
believe that it was the dependance on war and domination that
characterized the Caucasian People and shaped the changes in their
religion. Herding people or people whose livelihoods are tied up
with the behavior of great herds are not naturally war like or
"winner-take-all-like." Any help you can give me would be
appreciated.